Browse over 9,000 car reviews

Ask the Guide

Our team of experts are here to solve your car problems or help you decide which one to buy.

What value can I expect when selling my 2010 Holden Berlina International Wagon?

Answered by CarsGuide · 21 Feb 2023

I've personally seen a car just like this one with the same timing chain problem given away to a good home on the basis that fixing the engine problem was going to cost more than the car was worth. However, that was before the price-spike of a couple of years ago, and these cars are now worth more than they were back then.

Stretched timing chains in this engine are very common, and plenty of specialists have sprung up offering to change the timing chains for around the $2000 mark. If you have this work done, make sure the repairer uses the upgraded timing chain design which, hopefully, will stop the problem recurring.

In good running order, your Commodore wagon would be valued at somewhere between $5000 and $10,000 (depending on condition and mileage) but in its current state, the cost of repairs plus the hassle of buying a car needing lots of work is probably a deal breaker for a lot of buyers. Perhaps having the work done and then trying to sell it would make a better business case.

Show More

Is a new turbo covered under my Mazda's warranty?

Answered by CarsGuide · 21 Feb 2023

I'd need to know a bit more about this case to really know where you stand here. Was the whole engine (including the turbocharger) replaced at the same time? Or was the basic engine replaced and the existing accessories (such as the turbo) carried over form the original engine? If the latter is the case, then the turbo would not be covered by the new engine's warranty. But if it was all replaced as a brand-new engine, then you might find the turbocharger is, indeed, covered by the warranty.

But here's where it gets a bit murky. You say the new engine was supplied by Mazda, so presumably, that was at a Mazda dealership. Did they fit a genuine Mazda replacement engine, or was it a reconditioned engine sourced independently? This, too, can have a huge effect on what warranty comes with the replacement engine and what's actually included in the warranty.

Show More

The rear left and right brake/stop lights in my 2009 Dodge Nitro are not working

Answered by CarsGuide · 21 Feb 2023

If the third brake light is working, then the problem is not with the brake-pedal switch (or the third light would not work either). That the two lower brake lights stopped working together is also a clue that it's not the bulbs that are at fault.

I'd be looking at the fusebox to see if the fuse that controls the lower brake-light circuit has failed. There should be a map of the fusebox inside the plastic cover, and from that, you can identify which fuse protects that circuit, and go from there. If there's no blown fuse at fault, you need to start checking earth connections as these can also cause all sorts of electrical mayhem. An auto electrician could probably sort this quite quickly without changing any more working parts.

Show More

My Nissan X-Trail is making a juddering and knocking sound

Answered by CarsGuide · 21 Feb 2023

You've certainly gone to some extremes to check this out, but your investigations should give you a good clue that the problem is with front axle. So, it could either be the differential that is clattering and making the car judder or, perhaps more likely, the front CV joints which allow the car to drive its front axle while also steering the vehicle. Once you take the load off the front driveshafts (by disconnecting them) the noise stops because the worn CV joints aren't taking the strain of trying to move the car, so they don't make the horrible noise.

In some cases, you can simply replace the worn out CV joints, but there's also the option of complete driveshafts (with new CV joints already fitted) that are a simpler fix if a bit more costly. You can also buy driveshafts new or reconditioned. Its sounds like you're more than skilled enough to tackle this at home.

Show More

I replaced the starting battery in my 2014 Mazda BT-50 and now I have the powertrain light come on when driving

Answered by CarsGuide · 15 Feb 2023

It's quite probable that the check-engine light was triggered by the worn out condition of the battery you replaced, not the brand new one being fitted. Such cars hate low voltages, and that's precisely what a worn battery produces. That said, changing the battery can sometimes cause a modern, computerised car to throw a fault code, and when that happens, the check-engine light will illuminate.

You can try to re-set the vehicle's computer by disconnecting the battery and leaving it for an hour. Then reconnect the battery and see if the light has disappeared. If it hasn't, it may be that the computer simply needs to relearn a few parameters after having been disconnected from the power when the original battery change was made. A decent drive might return things to normal.

But don't forget the basics: Check the condition and cleanliness of the battery leads, terminals and make sure that all the connections are tight. If there's still no joy, have the vehicle electronically scanned and let the computer tell you precisely what's wrong.

Show More

What's the most reliable second-hand ute I can get for between 10-15k?

Answered by CarsGuide · 15 Feb 2023

If you're looking for a dual-cab ute with an emphasis on comfort and performance, then a Holden Crewman suddenly comes into sharp focus. These are around for the money you're talking about and even though some of them are getting close to your age cut-off, they provide ride quality and dynamics that even modern dual-cab utes struggle to reproduce.

The Holden in question is not an off-roader by any means, but it can do all the sorts of things that ute owners love them for. By going down this route, you also side-step the potentially troublesome common-rail diesel problems that can include blocked DPFs and internal clogging from soot and oil. If you can find one, there was even a V8 version of the Crewman which, if you find a good example, will provide lots of reliability and even more performance.

Show More

My 2015 Ford Kuga needs an engine replacement

Answered by CarsGuide · 15 Feb 2023

This crops us frequently as a dispute between car owners and dealerships and it's all because of one thing: Extended warranties are generally not worth the paper they're printed on. They're designed to relieve car buyers of more money, thinking they'll be covered if the worst happens. Usually, the warranty is carefully written to avoid paying out on the things most likely to go wrong. Never has 'read the fine print' been so important.

Consider that the warranty your purchased only covers the first $3500 of an engine replacement. Where on earth can an engine be replaced for that sort of money? It's a clear case of the fine print giving the warranty provider a convenient escape clause. Don't forget, this extended warranty is not a Ford factory warranty, it's a third party deal that car-dealers love because they get a kick-back from the warranty company every time a car buyer signs on that dotted line. Dealers also love these warranties because it forces owners into over-servicing their cars. Does it not seem strange that the car designed and engineered by Ford to have a 12-monthly service interval suddenly needs a six-monthly service as part of the warranty conditions?

As far as the replacement engine goes, be very careful about what you're being offered. If the engine is, indeed, a reconditioned engine, it doesn't really matter how many kilometres it has already done because reconditioned means it has been fully rebuilt with new parts. If, however, it's a second-hand engine plucked from a wrecked Kuga, then I would argue that an engine with the same mileage as the one in your car should be fitted. But I'll guarantee you there's some fine print in that warranty that makes me wrong about that, too.

Show More

My Holden SS V8 commodore is chugging

Answered by CarsGuide · 15 Feb 2023

The first thing to do is make sure your battery is earthed properly and all the relevant electrical contacts are tight and clean. Low voltage or a poor connection can easily cause the problems you're seeing, especially if they've all occurred more or less at the same time.

The next thing is to have the vehicle electronically scanned. That will tell you what faults the on-board computer has spotted, and you can then tackle them logically instead of replacing parts that don't fix the actual problem. The rough running could be anything from a dud oxygen sensor to a fuel-injection problem and lots in between.

I would suspect the heating and air-conditioning problems are separate to the engine's poor running, but anything's possible when a car's electronics start playing up.

Show More

Does an over-heating radiator cause slipping in automatic transmission gears?

Answered by CarsGuide · 15 Feb 2023

Many automatic vehicles have their transmission cooled as part of the car's engine cooling system. The transmission fluid passes through plumbing that takes it through (usually) the bottom tank of the car's radiator where it's cooled, keeping the entire transmission at the correct operating temperature.

So, if there was a problem with any of this cooling network or the radiator itself, it's entirely possible that the transmission could start to overheat. When that happens, all sorts of problems arise, including a loss of drive or slipping as it's also referred to.

The other major cause of transmission slip is a low transmission fluid level. Because the transmission in most cases is a sealed system which doesn't require fluid top-ups, many owners simply forget about it altogether. In a lot of modern cars, manufacturers don't even provide a dipstick with which to check the fluid level. But if there's a leak – even a small one – anywhere in the system, the fluid inside the transmission can fall too low and slippage can be the result.

Show More

Does the 2014 Ford Ranger have a variable-voltage alternator?

Answered by CarsGuide · 7 Feb 2023

That model Ranger does, indeed, have what’s called a variable-voltage or `smart’ alternator. The idea is that when the car’s main battery is fully charged, the alternator reduces its workload to save fuel. But the reality is that the system doesn’t always recognise that accessories (like a second battery) have been fitted to the car. If that happens, the alternator doesn’t always make enough power to keep accessories like that second battery system fully charged. Which means that suddenly, your car-fridge won’t run overnight.

The good news is that this smart function is purely electronically controlled, and a Ford dealer can disable it for you, returning the alternator to conventional operation.

Show More

Pages